Monday, September 13, 2010

Corporate India’s quest for the ‘million dollar solution’


(Note: The write-up below aims at presenting different points of view or opinion on a commonly observed phenomenon in corporate India along with stressing on issues or concerns it highlights)


It’s common and natural for every business organization to seek better way of doing things so as to improve profitability and maximize growth. But what makes each of them unique is how they go about it.

Most companies (except those stellar startups which catapulted itself into the main league by riding on technology wave) in India have earned their place today by a going through a long drawn process of evolution. It had ingredients like efforts and ideas from various generations of entrepreneurs, owners and employees. Catalysts like global economic scenarios and political climate.

The difference is, as all of us will agree, today they are finding themselves in a very special and promising phase. Opportunities are immense, stakes are high, upside is unlimited and so is the downside. Any decision to do or not to, has a lot at stake, in fact sometimes even survival. So the vital question comes. Whom to trust and listen to in these times when they need the magical recipe for success?

Many Indian behemoths still carry a lot of confidants who normally start and end their career there, for them it’s an extension of their family. Also they have a growing share of migratory talent. However the growing fad now is that when you are looking for a solution worth millions of dollars, they increasingly prefer someone who asks a price of a million dollar or more. Might be because then it’s worth a million dollar or more in more than 1 way!

Yes they turn to the Ms, Bs and B4s….Now the crux of the matter is why Indian companies do so.

One reason could be they want someone to take a fresh view of things inside the company and industry and think out a solution. But then will any person in few months be able to get a better grasp of such things than a person who is in it for years or even decades. Majority may say no, as it seems more logical too. One counter argument that pops is that ‘may be there is no one inside a company who has the whole picture’. If that is true then how did such a situation arise? Is it that companies have grown so complex that no one has ever is able to get a comprehensive view. Or is it that companies have a veil of diplomacy and politics that forces or rather restricts people into their respective spheres of activity.

The 2nd reason could be that the management wants to go by the trend of getting the best names (professional agencies) to do their work. The 3rd reason that comes to my mind (may be not the best) is that there is no talent inside who could do the job done by agencies.

It’s not a good sign for the company in all the 3 cases, though not grave as the solution is to pay a million dollar and circumvent the 3 scenarios.

The catch is that things do not end there. The million dollar advisors will only give the strategic advice and the roadmap. The success however lies in ‘execution’ of these advices and prescriptions over a longer term. If any of the 3 scenarios above are true (may be the 2nd scenario is an exception – management’s fancy for best professional advisors) then proper execution is not guaranteed! So in short the ‘million dollar solution will turn out to be just a solution which costs a million’

Interestingly, don’t these scenarios force a rethink on many fronts or does it have more merit in looking ahead and paying a million or more in its quest for success and growth.

A fascinating thought that comes to my mind is ‘whether India Inc is taking the asset-light model (advocated for certain industries) too much further by going for a strategy/brain light model and helping to create or rather promote a TPO(1) (Thought Process Outsourcing) industry’!!

(1) The term Thought Process Outsourcing is already used by few other authors, though not exactly for the same meaning as used here.

Sunday, August 15, 2010

Mumbaikars are better humans?

Note: Please read ‘Mumbai’ as an element of a class of objects called metropolitan cities.

Opinions expressed below are based on inferences drawn from certain events and are neither conclusive nor indicative of author’s believes. It is rather a statement of an opinion based on few observations.


When talking about cities each of us picture it in various scales, depending on what one expects or hopes for. For e.g. for a mass retailer it’s a big market, same with the case of a builder. From a model’s point of view it’s a plethora of opportunities, same from the perspective of a young professional. Such definitions vary based on who is the person, but it all refers to the same ‘whole’ called city.

Interestingly all these various definitions won’t be suitable for the other classes of human settlement called towns/villages. The reason is obvious, the scale and magnitude provides cities this versatility. So does this qualification of cities causes the inhabitants to develop and exhibit few traits that’s not common to people else where?

Let’s look back to 12, August, 2010. In Mumbai on that day there was a call by few youngsters to boycott ride in autos and taxis (meter-jam) as a mark of protest against their refusal to take short fare trips. As usual, the message was passed on via mails, web etc. On that day I too decided to join them and took a bus journey to work place. On my travel from western suburbs to Central suburbs, found that the adoption rate of the call was 20-30%. Lot of youngsters (both working and students) was found to stick on to the proven mode of convenient and comparatively quick transportation – autos. Later while traveling back I found that things were back to normal and more than 90% of regular auto commuters were going back home as usual.

Anyone in Mumbai (especially the young crowd) will agree that given the state of things here, preferred mode of commutation is train or auto-taxi. So routes which trains don’t connect directly or are close by, people prefer auto-taxi. In spite of such wide spread call for meter-jam¸ why is it that the adoption rate was so low. Why the common interest/cause was given a push back and importance was given to personal priorities.

Will a similar boycott call get a better response in semi-urban or rural India or would it have been the same every where? Anyways I feel this incident, more than anything else highlights a trait in the behavior of Mumbaikars.

Selfishness is something innate in human nature and I always feel it is a trait that is not as bad as it is sometimes projected. To a certain extent (which varies from person to person) all of us are selfish. As long as the selfishness is controlled and is not resulting in an action that hinders the interests of others, its justified. This trait is also arguably one of the trump cards we (humans) had in our quest for evolution and superiority among fellow species in animal kingdom, or is it?

On the flip side, if we examine this trait is not so pronounced in human inhabitations which do not qualify as a city. The obvious reason might be the opportunities a city offers and the costs associated with it. Compared to a village or town city offers variety of livelihoods and virtually unlimited avenues to prosper. I am not telling that a village or town does not offer these benefits, but a city offers it more and that too at a very fast pace. So the race is to grab the top spot. In that rat race it is natural we put the self above the society.

Before concluding let me present the issue from another angle. Is it the pace of life, i.e. the struggle to do more in less time causing this behavior and ‘selfishness’ is the tag we wrongly attribute to it? One common feature of Mumbaikars that is widely discussed is, majority don’t know their neighbors in adjacent flats. Does this add substance to the earlier view that it’s all because of lack of time. Or is it that we all become too much engrossed or involved in ‘ourselves’ and that caused the shrinkage of our sphere of social activity.

Interestingly still there are lot of things we all need in common, we need security, good infrastructure etc and for all that we need an organization called ‘government’. And for those things that each one of us can ‘manage’ on our own we never bother to look at the government. PDS mean nothing to many of us, subsidy on gas mean nothing to few of us and the list goes on… So should we assume that for what all things each of us can ‘manage’ on our own we choose to cruise or trudge on our own and for the rest we depend upon the ‘society’.

Does this point towards the state of things going to come? For matters that are inconsequential to us we choose to be on our own and for the rest we join the herd and call it the society. So as time elapses and as man becomes wealthy and sophisticated will many forms of social organization (here it excludes those which are formed for entertainment or relaxation purposes and means only those which serve a common cause
)
like neighborhoods, governments etc loose its purpose or prominence?

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Layered City - An economic spectacle!

Its my first blog and before starting let me make a confession. Till now I have stayed away from blogs treating it as something to be despised.

But slowly as more and more people turned towards it including my friends who had already made it a routine in their daily lives, my antagonistic stance began evaporating.

So its the first raw attempt!

While roaming around in Mumbai, where I am staying for more than 3 years, one particular aspect has always caught my fancy. How well or how uniquely extremes co-exist in a single frame. Putting it more vividly, you can see a harmonic mix of traditional and cosmopolitan crowd (judged based on their dressing and behavioral trends) move around in close proximity. If I base my argument on an economic parameter, we could easily spot many super luxury cars (say S class, 7 series, A8) fighting for road space with dilapidated ricks. In the same manner you could also spot people who live foot to mouth sharing foot paths and public transport with the crowd who are on their way up to establish themselves in the coveted streets of the world (call it Wall-street, Dalal-street etc)

This assortment of extremes measured as per various well-defined and loosely defined parameters, in this magnitude or scale is something unique to Mumbai (this you can argue that I have surmised!)

The logical afterthought that comes next is what is the driving force behind this state of things. Is it scarcity of resources (in any form/nature) or is it something a result of imbalanced growth or policies (which I guess is now being addressed by 'inclusive-growth'). Or does it have a better logic which is oblivious to my intuitions!

My version of things would be that the city is layered, not via physical or even theoretical measures. But by the unknown demarcation which is governed and managed by the forces of economics (more fashionably complexity economics!). The layering, I believe is so precariously done that any moderate fluctuations in the economic forces acting on the system (here the city and the various constituents) could bring the system into a fluid (unstable) situation. But its not apocalyptic so as to bring the system to a grinding halt. However it will consume the resources like time and energy (in the form of human effort and related actions) to bring it back status quo.

Also the aftershocks of any such instability faced by the system could perpetuate to other neighboring ecosystems where the cause and effect is more visible to us and could be directly experienced.

Also as a disclaimer or as a personal opinion, I believe the branch of knowledge which deals with this phenomenon is also searching for answers to questions like; - what is the binding equation for this, how it started and where its headed to; like many other human quests in related streams....